You are reading a rare, detailed account of everyday life in Stateville Prison.

Click to read Paul's blog quoted on:
To contact Paul, please email:
or write him at the address shown in the right column. He will get your message personally.

Tuesday, June 30, 2009

Library -- June 23, 2009

When the prison is not on lockdown, each cell house has a library line run twice a week. Only 30 prisoners are permitted to go, and only once a week. A prisoner must submit a request to be approved for library use a week in advance. People representing themselves and with court deadlines are given priority, but you may make the list if you have legal research to do, copies to be made, or need access to your legal box stored in the library. Those who simply want to check out a recreational book to read almost never make the list.

I am fortunate to be on the library list usually every other week. I have excess legal materials that I cannot fit in my cell correspondence box that I need to review on occasion. I also tend to need to make copies of legal materials, letters, or notes that I have written. Mostly, however, I go to do legal research on a successive post conviction appeal. All my regular appeals have been denied or thrown out, but I continue to look for an avenue to get my case back into court. The State of Illinois and the court system do not want prisoners continuously trying to get their cases reheard, and have set very stringent laws preventing re-litigation. Even innocent prisoners have an extremely difficult time getting heard in court after they have exhausted their regular set of appeals. I agree with the state's desire for finality of conviction, but I also believe that justice should be sought at trial more vigorously, and especially on appeal where life and liberty have already been stripped away.

The library is several blocks from where prisoners line up outside of the cell house. We are escorted by a few guards who stop us every so often because the lines break up, or are not as orderly as the leading guard desires. Years ago, we did not line up to go to chow, yard, library, or other places. It was just a herd of inmates going here or there. Due to the administration's desire for more control, order, and security, we must now always walk in lines. The lines are a much more time consuming process, and it probably took us 20 to 30 minutes under today's hot sun to enter the library. The procession was particularly slow and loud once we got to the path next to the South yard where many people wanted to yell out to their friends or gang affiliates.

It was nice to leave the summer heat for the air conditioned library. It is not often that prisoners at Stateville feel air conditioning. The library is an "L" shaped area with tables and chairs on one side, and bookshelves on the other. A guard sits at a desk in the middle to see both sides. I sat down with an older white man, and began to go through my legal folders to determine my plan for the day. Inmates only get about an hour and a half at the library. I am usually hurried for time and like to get all "my ducks in a row" before starting.

Over a month ago, I put in Shepardization requests for several cases including Waldrop, Erickson, and Lucas v. O'Dea. The Waldrop case is about a granted successive post conviction due to the petitioner's former post conviction counsel's failure to attach, or try to get, necessary affidavits. Erickson is a case that permits defendants to raise ineffective assistance of direct appellate counsel on successive post conviction appeals, but only if you had the same lawyer on direct and collateral appeal, as I did. The federal Lucas v. O'Dea case is about due notice of charges. All of these cases are of interest to me, and I wanted to see if there were similar cases that I could read. However I was told my Shepardization request was still incomplete. I may end up waiting another month.

I went to the copy room to make some copies of case law and discovered that no copies were being made. The principal of the elementary and GED classes is in charge of the library. She made a rule that only so many copies could be made per month, despite the fact that we pay for them. Apparently, we went over our quota and no more copies will be made for the month of June. After hearing this, I took an inmate grievance form to fill out. The principal does not have the authority to set a quota system that infringes on prisoners' rights to prepare and research laws for appeal.

After completing my grievance, I went over my checklist of cases to read that may be helpful in filing a successive post conviction appeal. I found one, and went to the counter to be waited on. At Stateville, you cannot get a legal book for yourself. A prison worker must retrieve it in exchange for your ID card. This, unfortunately, is necessary here because prisoners often steal books and care less about others who may want to read them.

Back at my table, reading the case and taking notes, I was interrupted by the older man who wanted me to help him find a case in a book, and also to explain how to use the key system at the beginning of court rulings. I was not eager to help him. My time is limited, and I knew he was looking at cases already filed by his lawyer. "What good is it to do research after your case has been filed?" I asked. This is something he should have done before. I quickly found his case and managed to read the rest of my case before the guard was yelling, "Library is over."

As I stepped out into the heat, I was disappointed to get so little done. For years, I have been looking for a way to petition the court for a retrial. Apparently, I will be waiting longer.

1 comment:

  1. At Centralia CC I put in two requests per week for the library and was always given two call passes a week even if my only purpose for being there was to check out new novels. I guess that's the difference between Maximum Security and Low-Medium Security. Also we were never escorted by guards except during chow lines.Once you were issued a call pass you just left your cell house and went on your merry way to your destination. Thanks for sharing your life with us Paul.


If you choose Name / URL, you can write any name and you don't need a URL. Or you can choose Anonymous. Paul loves getting your Comments. They are all mailed to him.